Appraisal vs. Home Inspection
Understanding the differences and why both matter
Two Different Evaluations
Many homebuyers and sellers confuse appraisals with home inspections, but they serve distinctly different purposes in a real estate transaction. While both involve examining a property, the goals, scope, and outcomes are fundamentally different.
Understanding these differences helps you know what to expect from each process and why both are typically necessary when buying or selling a home.
Quick Comparison
Appraisal
Primary Purpose
Determine market value for lending purposes
Performed By
Licensed/Certified Appraiser
For Whom
Lender (required for mortgage)
Focus
Market value and comparable sales
Typical Cost
$500 - $2,000+ (varies by property)
Duration
30-60 minutes on-site
Home Inspection
Primary Purpose
Evaluate property condition and identify defects
Performed By
Licensed Home Inspector
For Whom
Buyer (optional but recommended)
Focus
Structural integrity and system functionality
Typical Cost
$400 - $800+ (varies by property)
Duration
2-4 hours on-site
What is an Appraisal?
An appraisal is an unbiased professional opinion of a property's market value. The appraiser's job is to determine what a willing buyer would likely pay a willing seller in the current market.
What Appraisers Do:
- ✓Measure the property to verify square footage
- ✓Photograph interior, exterior, and surrounding area
- ✓Assess overall condition and quality of construction
- ✓Research and analyze comparable sales
- ✓Consider market trends and location factors
- ✓Provide a final opinion of market value
What Appraisers Don't Do:
- ✗Perform detailed inspections of systems or components
- ✗Move furniture or test appliances
- ✗Identify hidden defects or future problems
- ✗Provide repair cost estimates
- ✗Guarantee the condition of the property
What is a Home Inspection?
A home inspection is a thorough examination of a property's physical condition and systems. The inspector's job is to identify existing and potential problems that could affect safety, functionality, or require future repairs.
What Home Inspectors Do:
- ✓Examine structural components (foundation, framing, roof)
- ✓Test all mechanical systems (HVAC, plumbing, electrical)
- ✓Check for water damage, mold, and pest issues
- ✓Inspect roof, gutters, and drainage
- ✓Test appliances and built-in systems
- ✓Identify safety hazards and code violations
- ✓Provide detailed report with photos of issues found
- ✓Recommend repairs and maintenance
What Home Inspectors Don't Do:
- ✗Determine property value or market price
- ✗Guarantee or certify the property
- ✗Perform specialized inspections (termite, environmental)
- ✗Look inside walls or beneath floors
- ✗Predict future problems or lifespan of components
Key Differences
| Aspect | Appraisal | Home Inspection |
|---|---|---|
| Objective | Determine market value | Assess physical condition |
| Required By | Lender (mandatory) | Buyer (optional) |
| Depth of Examination | Visual overview | Detailed investigation |
| Testing | None | Systems, outlets, appliances |
| Comparable Analysis | Yes, extensive | No |
| Repair Recommendations | Only if affecting value | Detailed list provided |
| Report Delivered To | Lender (copy to buyer) | Buyer directly |
| Can Affect Transaction | Yes, determines loan amount | Yes, buyer may request repairs |
When You Need Each One
You Need an Appraisal When:
- •Buying a home with a mortgage (lender requirement)
- •Refinancing your existing mortgage
- •Removing PMI from your mortgage
- •Settling an estate or divorce
- •Appealing property taxes
- •Making investment decisions
You Need a Home Inspection When:
- •Buying any property (especially older homes)
- •You want to know the true condition before purchasing
- •Planning major renovations
- •Concerned about specific issues (foundation, roof, etc.)
- •Want leverage for repair negotiations
- •Preparing to sell (pre-listing inspection)
Why You Need Both
In most real estate transactions, you'll need both an appraisal and a home inspection because they serve complementary purposes:
The Appraisal Protects the Lender
It ensures the bank isn't lending more money than the property is worth. If the appraisal comes in below the purchase price, you'll need to renegotiate, bring more cash, or walk away.
The Inspection Protects the Buyer
It reveals the property's condition and potential problems. This information helps you make an informed decision and negotiate repairs or price adjustments before closing.
Important: An Appraisal Is Not a Substitute for an Inspection
A property can appraise at full value while having significant defects that would be revealed in a home inspection. Never skip the inspection thinking the appraisal covers condition assessment—it doesn't.
Typical Timeline in a Transaction
Offer Accepted
Contract includes inspection and appraisal contingencies
Home Inspection (Days 5-10)
Buyer schedules and pays for inspection; receives detailed report
Appraisal Ordered (Days 7-10)
Lender orders appraisal once loan application is complete
Repair Negotiations (Days 10-15)
Based on inspection, buyer may request repairs or credits
Appraisal Complete (Days 15-20)
Appraisal report delivered; confirms value for loan approval
Final Approval & Closing (Days 25-30)
Loan approved based on appraisal; transaction closes
Common Misconceptions
Myth: "The appraiser will find all the problems with the house"
Reality: Appraisers perform visual assessments only. They don't test systems, move furniture, or conduct invasive examinations. That's the inspector's job.
Myth: "If it appraises well, I don't need an inspection"
Reality: A property can have significant hidden defects while still appraising at market value. Always get an inspection.
Myth: "The inspection will affect the appraisal value"
Reality: Appraisers typically work independently and don't see inspection reports unless specific issues are disclosed.
Myth: "I can use an inspection instead of an appraisal for my lender"
Reality: Lenders require appraisals by licensed appraisers. Inspections cannot substitute for appraisals.
The Bottom Line
Appraisals tell you what a property is worth in the current market.
Inspections tell you what condition the property is in and what it might cost to maintain.
For a complete picture when buying a home, you need both. The appraisal protects your lender's investment, while the inspection protects yours.
Need a Professional Appraisal?
Get an accurate, unbiased property valuation from certified Bay Area experts